Welcome to my website! For information about my editing and indexing services, please view the pages listed on the left. Thank you!

Tuesday, May 29, 2012

The Secret Cows of My Furtive Imagination

There are garden-variety solecisms—such as the confusion between reluctant and reticent—that annoy in a particularly dull and unedifying way. They bring out the worst elitist and prescriptivist tendencies in people (I mean me), and whenever I start writing about them on this blog I inevitably delete the posts because I just don't want to sound so peevish in public.

But luckily for this blog, there are errors of another kind—folk misconceptions of language that are so startling that all you can do is laugh and be happy. My brother-in-law collects these as a way of tholing through his life of harmless drudgery—yesterday, he says, he heard someone on the radio say "secret cow" for "sacred cow."

I'm sure it's out there, but the only real example I could find on the Internet was in a speech given by the chair of the South Sudan Anti-Corruption Commission: "... our daily focus will be on junior government officers handling financial matters. There shall be no 'secret cows' this time, big or small we shall endorse the panel laws against any corrupt individual or organisation."

A sacred cow, much like a certain kind of civil servant, is something you can't question or criticize. If you thought such a person was hiding in plain sight, and you were a little rusty on your comparative religion, I can see how you might think a sacred cow was in fact a secret cow.   

I once heard a TV journalist say "follow the suits" in an approximation of "follow suit," and found through a Google search that a small (but no doubt growing) group of people seem to believe that "follow the suits" is the idiom. I guess it was inevitable. Suit is a somewhat derogatory term for an establishment figure or professional; the Internet abounds with (legitimate) sentences like "follow the suits to the best after-hours bars."

But if the card-playing metaphor in "follow suit" was opaque to you, and you thought the point was to follow in the footsteps of a figure of authority, then of course sentences like the following make perfect sense:

I have come to narrate the saga of those brave men and women and urge fellow countries to follow the suits 
if you look at all the scriptures from the Koran to the Bible and the Torah theres a lot of things that are quite similar and they all follow the suits of what scientist said
One last thing: given the number of adjectives that begin with f plus some sort of schwa-like vowel, it's no wonder at all that they become all jumbled up in people's minds. Thus, in place of the "fervid imagination" or even the "fertile imagination," we also have the "fetid imagination" and the "furtive imagination." While I can see that some people's imaginations are undeniably fetid, I have some trouble understanding how one's imagination could be furtive. Have you ever had a fantasy that refused to show itself? Perhaps I should bone up on my Freud. Perhaps, in the alpine reaches of his mind, he kept a secret cow or two.

Tuesday, December 6, 2011

The Noughties

I was startled recently, while reading a Straits Times article about the proposed North-South expressway, to see the following sentence: "Several feasibility studies have been done on it, some dating back to the early noughties."

I remember hearing about "the aughts" as a possible term for the first decade of our present century, a usage apparently modelled on one popular in the early 20th century. But "the aughts" doesn't appear to have caught on. To me it sounds a little too WASP-y—it makes me think of boater hats and spatterdashers and vapid young men wearing Harold Lloyd glasses.   

But is "the noughties" really preferable? The Wikipedia article on the decade—entitled, by the way, "2000s (decade)"—claims that the BBC listed "noughties" as a "potential moniker for the new decade," and that the word has since become "the only term for the decade in common use in the UK." I guess this is why the Straits Times adopted it, out of some naive notion that if the English use it, it must be OK. Not so, I say!

The trouble with "the noughties" is that 1) nobody outside the UK uses "nought" very much, aside from a certain generation, now probably retired, of Convent-school math teacher; 2) the suffix -ties, derived from -ty in numerals like twenty and thirty and so on, can't be stuck on to nought because there is no such word or number as *noughty.

For me, "noughties" sounds too much like the tongue-in-cheek media catchphrase that it is. I don't know whether "in common use in the UK" means it has been adopted into stylesheets as standard usage—if so, that strikes me as remarkably tone-deaf.

I expect the beef against "early 2000s" is that some newspaper or press stylesheets direct their editors to spell out the decades, i.e. nineties and not  90s. The thought of using numerals for the one decade and not others must send a few people into copy-editing conniptions.

But that seems a lot less gauche to me than "noughties."

Wednesday, June 15, 2011

Minim Confusion and Pig's Organ Soup

I saw this sign at the temporary location of the Hong Lim hawkers' centre last time I was in Singapore. It took me a minute to figure out what had gone wrong. I rather think it had to do with minim confusion.

The minim is the short, vertical stroke that is used for forming the letters i, u, m and n. The word minim is itself formed out of 10 minims! I don't know much about palaeography, so I can't go on at length about this, but a run of juxtaposed minims can be hard to distinguish in manuscripts—is that u or n? An m or in?

The practice of dotting i's solved part of the problem. Replacing minim-formed vowels with others did the trick too. It's thought that our spellings of love, son and woman—all with unhistorical o's—stemmed from a desire to reduce minim confusion in words that were, at various stages of Old and Middle English, spelled luue, sunu and wimman.

So I imagine that the signmaker for this hawker stall had been handed a note specifying that the words Pig's Innard should appear, but as a result of some understandable minim confusion (innard is not among the most frequently encountered of English words), he wrote Lunard instead.

It's somehow rather nice to think that my Hong Lim hawker's signmaker was stymied by the same difficulty that sometimes beset medieval scribes.

Incidentally, to the left of pig's lunard appeared a notice for pig's trottles. Behind that, I think, is another story ...

Friday, January 14, 2011

At the Other End ...

... of the spectrum of linguistic competence, this notice I found taped to a malfunctioning bank machine in Coronation Plaza.


In a way, you have to pay tribute to the work that went into the composition of this notice. You can almost hear the gears turning in the author's mind, as more formulaic options such as "Not Working" or "Out of Order" signally failed to present themselves. So carefully specified are space, time, and the existential salience of the "promblem" that, in the end, there was only enough energy left over for a singular "thank."

It's too bad. I really needed to update my passbook.

Saturday, January 1, 2011

Coffee Shop Paronomasia

I saw this sign on a recent trip to Katong (in the eastern part of Singapore) and thought it was a very good example of a bilingual pun.

The Chinese says A li ba ba yi ding hao, which of course approximates the sound of the English rather well, and means "Ali Baba is sure to be good!"

I like the way the Chinese version eschews representing the final consonant of house. They could so easily have rendered it A li ba ba yi ding hao chi (Ali Baba is sure to be good eating), but that would have ruined the syllabic count!

Monday, September 27, 2010

A Whopping Big Number

When did whopping become obligatory before large numbers?

I first noticed it in my students' essays ("Shakespeare wrote a whopping 38 plays" and the like). But since then I don't think I have ever failed to see whopping inserted where attention to a large number was intended to be drawn. Why, just this morning I read that "a whopping 23,000 applications" had been submitted to the Ontario Power Authority for a green retrofit program. And while surfing the web earlier I saw this fearsome headline: "Worst Milkshake Packs A Whopping 2010 Calories"!

Sometimes, the adjective is used in irony (I see someone entitled their blog post "A Whopping TWO New Jerseyans Sign Up for Obamacare Benefits"), but as often as not whopping is inserted with all apparent sincerity, even in serious journalism and scholarly writing. This despite the fact that the Oxford English Dictionary labels its use colloquial or vulgar.

It's like the expression piping hot. People just like to put that word piping in before hot, especially at the end of recipes, where the aspiring cook is enjoined to serve the dish p— h—. The phrase has the reassurance of ubiquity; it may be assumed to be safely idiomatic.

The word whop (first attested in the 16th century) means "to strike with heavy blows; beat soundly, flog, thrash, belabour (a person or animal; rarely, an inanimate object." The OED also deems whop in its various senses colloquial or vulgar.

Whopping, as a participial adjective meaning "abnormally large or great; 'whacking,' 'thumping,'" is first attested in 1625. In 1818, Walter Scott wrote with sartorial enthusiasm in Rob Roy, "What a wapping weaver he was, and wrought my first pair o' hose." Curiously, none of the citations listed in OED place whopping with a number.

I wonder if, in the minds of some (no, a great many) writers, whopping has come to corner the intensifying-adjective-before-big-number lexical market. Perhaps I could suggest a few competitors of a higher register: impressive (as in "Ad Spend on Social Networks Gains Impressive Half-Point in Share") perhaps; or colossal ("Bill Adds Colossal $2 Billion to Deficit"); or, if you're hyperbolically inclined, astronomical ("Fourth Quarter Profit Soars an Astronomical 244%").

Come to think of it, the possibilities are endless. "Profits Shrink by a Crushing 40%"; or "House Sells for Mouth-Gaping $14 Million"; or "Cat Weighs in at Shriek-Inducing 40 Pounds".

But now I've come to a realization. Sometimes, in writing, a vulgar colloquialism is exactly what's called for. Time for a whopping 2010-calorie milkshake.

Sunday, September 26, 2010

Good News

I learned this week that the Boldprint Graphic Novel series has won the 2011 Learning Magazine Teacher's Choice for Children's Book Award. I am the author of four titles in the series — Castaway Island, Kingdom of the Snow Cat, Operation Fly South, and Turtle Rescue.
     The series is published jointly by Rubicon Publishing and Oxford University Press. It had previously won the 2010 Texty Award for Textbook Excellence from the Text and Academic Authors Association.
     It seemed like the kind of news that might merit a blog post!